Juliet Capulet (euphoric1dr) wrote in linguaphiles,
Juliet Capulet
euphoric1dr
linguaphiles

passive and active voice

As I teach here in Taiwan, many times I'm told to teach the passive voice to students, and my roommate and I disagree on whether this is correct or not.

EXAMPLE: I ate an apple (active)

The apple was eaten by me (passive)

She argues that passive voice is wrong. I argue that this is something perhaps special about the English language and some others. The fact that - English allows for this flexibility and linguistic mobility. (It's a little crazy sometimes I'll admit - after I teach these kinds of lessons, I find myself turning EVERYTHING into passive/active in my head! I will call my mom...my mom will be callled by me...lol)

Anyway. If it is wrong, why do they even teach it to us in the first place?

My roommate's answer is, they TEACH passive voice or construction, to make us understand that it is wrong and that we should never use it.

But another example; such as...

The girl took some medicine.
Some medicine was taken by the girl.

I don't see anything WRONG about either...grammatically, aren't they correct?

Please try and clear up this confusion if you can - thanks guys!! =)
Subscribe

  • Hawaiian: questions

    Hey everyone! I'm trying to learn Hawaiian. Has anyone tried before and if so does anyone here have any advice or tips? Also, what are some online…

  • Anyone speak Hawaiian?

    Can somebody translate "reach for the stars," or "strive for the stars," or something to that effect? Any help would be much appreciated. Thanks in…

  • hawaiian update

    I've been trying to find information on the state of the Hawaiian language. I'm curious if anyone hear has any experience with it. I feel embarrassed…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 76 comments
Previous
← Ctrl ← Alt
Next
Ctrl → Alt →
Previous
← Ctrl ← Alt
Next
Ctrl → Alt →

  • Hawaiian: questions

    Hey everyone! I'm trying to learn Hawaiian. Has anyone tried before and if so does anyone here have any advice or tips? Also, what are some online…

  • Anyone speak Hawaiian?

    Can somebody translate "reach for the stars," or "strive for the stars," or something to that effect? Any help would be much appreciated. Thanks in…

  • hawaiian update

    I've been trying to find information on the state of the Hawaiian language. I'm curious if anyone hear has any experience with it. I feel embarrassed…