Anonymous (ulvesang) wrote in linguaphiles,
Anonymous
ulvesang
linguaphiles

Grammatical Gender: A Non-Sapir-Whorfist Analysis?

Is anyone familiar with any publications which describe or hypothesise why/how grammatical gender/noun classes developed in a language or languages without resorting to fuzzy pseudo-sociolinguistic/cultural arguments, which are usually tautologies in any case (e.g. "in the Spanish-speaking world, the moon embodies typically feminine qualities")?

The only "practical" function of them I can find is the possibility of n-way anaphoric binding for n genders - e.g. German Er liegt zwischen ihm und ihr ('he lies between it and her') could accurately describe the placement of utensils on a dining table (der Löffel 'the spoonMASC', das Messer 'the knifeNEUT', die Gabel 'the forkFEM')... or for the confusion of 2nd-language learners. However, while some languages feature 10 or more noun classes (e.g. Bantu languages), there are a great many languages which work just fine without any.

(Granted, this argument could hold reasonably well for inflection, lexical accent, lexical tone, tense, aspect...)
Tags: gender
Subscribe

  • Gender-neutral Spanish pronouns?

    I'm working on a speculative fiction story that needs gender-neutral Spanish pronouns. My Spanish is rusty (and was never very sophisticated to…

  • Types of pronouns across languages

    Long time lurker de-lurking for the first time in...quite a while. So, in many (West?) European languages, pronouns are usually broken down to…

  • Gendered first-person pronouns in Japanese?

    In a recent IRC discussion, someone mentioned that Japanese first-person pronouns could be gendered in some contexts. That got my attention, because…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 36 comments

  • Gender-neutral Spanish pronouns?

    I'm working on a speculative fiction story that needs gender-neutral Spanish pronouns. My Spanish is rusty (and was never very sophisticated to…

  • Types of pronouns across languages

    Long time lurker de-lurking for the first time in...quite a while. So, in many (West?) European languages, pronouns are usually broken down to…

  • Gendered first-person pronouns in Japanese?

    In a recent IRC discussion, someone mentioned that Japanese first-person pronouns could be gendered in some contexts. That got my attention, because…