. (ein_suender) wrote in linguaphiles,


In addition to watching French in Action, I've also started the 16-lesson level Pimsleur CDs.

I have one question about the CDs. On the first lesson, they say "Vous êtes américain." to mean "You are an American." Then they say "Je suis américain." to mean "I am American."

I understand that much. The thing I don't understand is when it is reversed, and turned into a question:

"Est-que vous êtes américain?"

However, the way I've been learning it up till now is that to ask a question like that, you could just say:

"Vous êtes américain?" (leaving off the "Est-que.")

Are both of these correct? And can you use "Est-que" to turn any statement into a question, like that?

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded